Fox Legal Analyst Wrong – Federal Cops Doing Things Right in Portland

Gage Skidmore from Peoria, AZ, United States of America via Wikimedia Commons

The battle lines in Portland and the media are hardening. As federal law enforcement officers deploy to protect federal buildings and monuments against increasingly violent rioters, the media is also escalating its information war. Even analysts on Fox News are adding to the misleading hysteria.

While it is easier to dismiss biased reporting from the establishment media on a controversial Trump topic such as this, critical commentary from a prominent Fox analyst is different.

Fox News senior judicial analyst, and former New Jersey Superior Court judge, Andrew Napolitano, recently slammed the Trump administration for sending federal law enforcement to Portland, Oregon, calling the move “unconstitutional” and “just plain wrong.”

Sadly, in this case, Napolitano is the one who is just “plain wrong.”

“You have anarchy on one hand,” Napolitano said Monday, according to The Hill, adding that, “If the troops come in the streets, you have a potential for even more violence on the other hand.”

Later, on Tuesday, reported Fox News, Napolitano said, “Federal agents in Portland, Ore., must confine their law enforcement duties to the protection of federal assets and wear uniforms that identify them,” adding, ‘They have to be restrained’ – referring to what Federal agents in Portland can and cannot do.  He added that they simply can’t enforce general criminal laws.

First, let us address the judge’s first comment where he calls the federal officers’ “troops” – an obviously incorrect and inflammatory reference. These are all duly appointed law civilian law enforcement officers – calling them troops is deceiving and “just plain wrong.” And President Trump sending them to Portland is in no way “unconstitutional” – and Napolitano knows better.

Also, Judge, since when do our political leaders refrain from enforcing the law and control “anarchy” out of fear the anarchists will get more violent?

Napolitano is correct that federal law enforcement officers sent to cities facing rioting are limited in what they can do, and as he stated, according to Fox News, “They can’t supplement or replace the police,” Napolitano explained. “They can’t go throughout the streets and say, ‘Hey, you’re committing a crime. We’re going to arrest you.’”

However, Napolitano’s jumping on the left-wing media bandwagon claiming that these officers have gone beyond that scope and are just detaining people arbitrarily – is based on incomplete and misleading news reporting. This is unprofessional and that narrative is also “just plain wrong.”

Napolitano steps into the fire when he claims, according to Fox News that:

They certainly can’t do what they have been doing in Oregon, which is arresting people without a warrant and without probable cause, holding them for a few hours and then letting them go…So they have to be restrained and they have to confine their activity to the federal property.

While out-of-context videos or biased reports from protestors can be used to paint a nefarious picture of feds randomly picking up innocent people on the streets, facts provided by court records about how the federal officers are operating shows a very different reality.

As local news outlet, OregonLive reported, “Feds conduct surveillance from courthouse, analyze social media videos, post undercover agents in crowds,” to decide who to detain or arrest. Using court records from recent cases, the outlet reported:

Federal officers have conducted surveillance of protesters from upper floors of the downtown …Courthouse, analyzed live nightly video footage and posted undercover agents among crowds to arrest people on allegations ranging from shining lasers at officers to breaking plywood protecting courthouse doors, federal records reveal.

Federal officers also have shared some of their information with Portland police officers, who assisted them in at least one arrest earlier this month, the documents disclose.

OregonLive added:

Federal agents have taken photos of people committing vandalism and reviewed video of action outside the courthouse, sometimes relying on live streams from demonstrators or independent journalists shared via Twitter, YouTube or other social media, according to federal officers and prosecutors.

They have monitored people before wading into crowds to make arrests — sometimes waiting for hours until the gatherings have thinned…

These records seem to show that the federal officers in Portland are not randomly snatching people off the street, but simply waiting for the opportune and safest moment to apprehend suspects who attacked federal assets or personnel earlier. Other times they pass their intelligence to local law enforcement. All perfectly legal and appropriate.

Perhaps Napolitano and other uninformed critics should do some research to understand how the feds are really operating in Portland, before giving their “expert” opinion.

AdvertisementInsert alt text here

Advertisement
Support the Landmark Lawsuit Against Antifa

Paul Crespo

Paul Crespo is the Managing Editor of American Defense News. A defense and national security expert, he served as a Marine Corps officer and as a military attaché with the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) at US embassies worldwide. Paul holds degrees from Georgetown, London, and Cambridge Universities. He is also CEO of SPECTRE Global Risk, a security advisory firm, and President of the Center for American Defense Studies, a national security think tank.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
8 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Rivahmitch
Rivahmitch
1 year ago

Nappy is a fool. We’re currently experiencing open warfare in our streets but only one side is really fighting. Fact: You can’t win either a war of a sports activity by ONLY paying defense.

Floyd Hale
Floyd Hale
1 year ago

Pare for the course !!!!!!

Robert Ayres
Robert Ayres
1 year ago

Judge my ass , he is pissed because trump wouldn’t appoint him a seat in the administration! Just another leftist scumbag!!!!

Jody Parker
Jody Parker
1 year ago

Well sadly he is never right any more. So many of these men are jealous of President Trump and just cannot control themselves????

Good luck
Good luck
1 year ago

Hay, Napo , you just going to set their and let them destroy the whole town. Time to stop the destruction . You can protest all you want, but thats with out burning , looting, smashing windows .

Robert
Robert
1 year ago

Where in our Constitution does it say that elected officials should allow looting, burning, killing, assault and destruction of we the peoples property? Napolitano is like every other elite = as long as it doesn’t affect where I live then I can allow the collateral damage done to American citizens. Aren’t we sick and tired of these asinine talking heads lecturing we the people on their opinions????????

Ernst
Ernst
1 year ago

FORMER New Jersey Superior Court judge Andrew Napolitano gets things wrong so often it s pitiful. Fox News should dump this mentally dissipated clown. Nice (empty) suit with no brain.

Anna
Anna
1 year ago

Napolitano is always wrong since President refused to nominate him to Supreme Court. And THANKS GOD FOR IT. AG should give him lecture on Constitution. Hack needs to disbar, looks like the law he is practicing has nothing to do with our nation law.


People, Places & Things